A self-directed IRA (SDIRA) is an IRA held with a custodian that allows it to invest in alternative assets, such as real estate, private lending, private funds, startups, precious metals and crypto, as well as stocks, bonds and mutual funds.
It isn’t a separate type of IRA under the tax code. A self-directed Traditional or Roth IRA follows the same tax rules as any other IRA. The limitation is typically not the tax code. It is the custodian holding the account.
Mat Sorensen, CEO of Directed IRA and tax attorney, walks through how it works in the video below.
Most U.S. retirement accounts are held at large financial institutions that offer publicly traded assets: stocks, bonds, mutual funds and ETFs. These firms rarely support alternative investments like real estate or private companies, because they’re harder to administer and don’t generate commissions or management fees for the firm. Simply put, Wall Street firms are in the business of selling Wall Street products.
IRAs have been allowed to invest in alternative assets for decades. What you need is a custodian that supports them. Directed IRA is a licensed trust company that doesn’t sell investments, so its focus is on letting clients invest in the assets they choose.
| What the account can hold | Brokerage IRA | Self-directed IRA |
|---|---|---|
| Stocks and ETFs | Yes | Yes |
| Mutual funds | Yes | Yes |
| Real estate | No | Yes |
| Private lending | No | Yes |
| Private funds | No | Yes |
| Startups and private companies | No | Yes |
| Crypto | Limited | Yes |
| Precious metals | Limited | Yes |
| Deals you find yourself | No | Yes |
The key difference is that a self-directed IRA can invest in private assets and specific deals that you identify and evaluate.
Self-directing isn’t limited to one kind of account. Each of these can hold alternative assets at Directed IRA:
The difference isn’t the tax treatment of the account. It’s what the custodian allows the account to hold.
One of the biggest misconceptions about retirement accounts is that they have to stay invested on Wall Street. In reality, the general rule is that an IRA can invest in anything the law allows, unless it’s specifically prohibited.
Not allowed: collectibles (art, antiques, rugs, stamps and most collectible coins), life insurance, and S-corporation stock. Precious metals must meet IRS fineness standards and be stored with a depository, not at home.
Real estate is the most popular self-directed investment. When it’s set up properly, the IRA owns the property, receives the income, pays the expenses and receives any gain when it sells. With private lending, the IRA acts as the lender and receives the interest and the repayment of principal. Private funds let investors join professionally managed deals, and startups and private companies appeal to investors with expertise in a particular industry. Crypto and precious metals round out the options.
The bigger limit usually isn’t the asset itself. It’s how the deal is structured and who the IRA is dealing with.
The main reason is simple: investors want retirement account tax benefits on investments outside the stock market. The tax treatment works the same whether the IRA owns Apple stock or a rental property.
If the IRA buys an investment for $100,000 and later sells it for $150,000, the full $150,000 goes back into the IRA. There’s no capital gains tax inside the account. A Traditional IRA grows tax-deferred, and you pay income tax when you take money out. A Roth IRA grows tax-free, and qualified withdrawals are tax-free.
That’s why most self-directed investors invest in what they know. A real estate investor buys rentals, a lender makes private loans, and someone who works in tech backs a startup they understand.
The IRA is the investor, not you personally. Every investment involves the same three parts:
The custodian’s role is administrative. It confirms that an asset can be held lawfully and administratively, not whether it’s a good investment, so due diligence is always the IRA owner’s job. Here’s how to choose a self-directed IRA custodian.
Open a self-directed IRA with a custodian that allows alternative assets.
Move part of an existing IRA, roll over an old 401(k), or make this year’s contribution.
Find the deal and review it before you commit any funds.
Send a direction letter. The documents name the IRA, and the custodian sends the funds.
Open and fund the account before you commit to a deal. Finding the deal first is one of the most common causes of delayed closings. Many investors transfer only part of an existing IRA rather than moving the whole account, and a former employer’s 401(k) can be rolled over. You can also add this year’s contribution.
After that, keep all activity inside the IRA. The IRA receives all income and pays all expenses.
The prohibited transaction rules are the most important concept in self-directed investing. They keep a retirement account from being used for your personal benefit today.
Even with people who aren’t disqualified, every deal must be at arm’s length, on the same terms the IRA would get from a stranger.
Breaking these rules can disqualify the entire IRA. The account is treated as distributed on January 1 of that year, which means income tax on a Traditional IRA, plus a 10% penalty if you’re under 59½. One helpful principle: the IRA is investing for retirement, not for your personal benefit today. Learn more about prohibited transactions in a self-directed IRA.
Here’s how the pieces fit together with a rental property:
Bought in the IRA’s name and paid for with IRA funds.
Rent goes into the IRA. Repairs, taxes and management are paid by the IRA.
The full sale price, including the $101,000 gain, goes back into the IRA.
Unlike a taxable investment, the gain stays inside the retirement account and keeps growing with its tax advantages. It’s one reason real estate remains one of the most popular self-directed investments. See how to buy real estate in an IRA.
Most investment income inside an IRA isn’t taxed, including rent, interest, dividends, royalties and capital gains. Two taxes can apply in specific cases:
They don’t apply to most self-directed investments, but review them before investing in an operating business, leveraged real estate or certain private funds. When they apply, the IRA files Form 990-T and pays the tax from IRA funds.
Most self-directed IRA mistakes are avoidable once you know the rules:
Self-directed investing isn’t for everyone. It can be a good fit if you:
It may not suit you if you prefer a fully hands-off approach or aren’t comfortable evaluating private investments. As Mat Sorensen puts it, if you don’t understand how an investment makes the returns being promised, don’t invest.
Is a self-directed IRA legal?
Yes. IRAs have been allowed to hold alternative assets for decades, and a self-directed IRA follows the same tax rules as any other IRA. See are self-directed IRAs safe?
Can I self-direct the IRA I already have?
Yes. A trustee-to-trustee transfer moves money from your current IRA custodian to Directed IRA with no tax or penalty, and you can move all of it or only part. See transfers and rollovers.
Do I need an IRA/LLC?
No. Most investments can be made directly by the IRA. Some investors add an IRA/LLC, sometimes called a checkbook IRA, so an LLC owned by the IRA can sign and pay for deals itself. It’s a tool, not a requirement.
Does Directed IRA recommend investments?
No. Directed IRA is a passive custodian. It doesn’t sell or endorse investments or give investment, legal or tax advice. It processes and reports the investments its clients choose and direct.
Directed IRA is a Tradename of Directed Trust Company, an Arizona-licensed trust company examined by the Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions and audited annually by outside CPA firms. It was founded by two tax attorneys, Mat Sorensen and Mark J. Kohler, and today holds more than 25,000 retirement accounts. You bring the investment, we handle the rest.
Prefer a live walkthrough? Watch the webinar replay, Self-Directed IRAs: Everything You Need to Know to Get Started, or book a free 15-minute call with our team.
Open a self-directed IRA online in as little as 5 minutes, then invest in real estate, private lending, private funds, crypto and other assets you know.
Open an AccountOr book a free 15-minute callDirected IRA is a Tradename of Directed Trust Company. Directed Trust Company performs the duties of a directed custodian, and as such does not provide due diligence to third parties on prospective investments, platforms, sponsors or service providers and does not sell investments or provide investment, legal, or tax advice. Examples on this page are hypothetical and for educational purposes only.
Our entire Directed IRA team is friendly, knowledgeable, and genuinely excited to help you. Reach out to any of our specialists today and take the first step toward self-directing your IRA or Solo 401(k)!
New to self-directed retirement accounts? These resources are designed to help you understand the fundamentals and get started the right way.
Access curated webinars, guides, and educational content covering investment options, account structures, and the rules that govern self-directed IRAs.
Mat Sorensen, Attorney, CEO, and Founder of Directed IRA, wrote the #1 book on self-directed IRAs – selling over 60,000 copies nationwide. The Self Directed IRA Handbook is a comprehensive guide written for both investors and advisors alike. Get access to your SDIRA Handbook resources today!
Mat Sorensen, Attorney, CEO, and Founder of Directed IRA, wrote the #1 book on self-directed IRAs – selling over 60,000 copies nationwide. The Self Directed IRA Handbook is a comprehensive guide written for both investors and advisors alike. Download your free copy today!